Not the best neighbors
Witają Polska, welcome to Poland. This land of the northern Slavs is a very old one, with a very concrete history and cultural identity. Unfortunately, most of that history and identity is that of the nation serving as a buffer between competing empires. Poland is particuarly interesting in that in the 10th Century, when most of Northern Europe was still toasting to Woden in wooden feasting halls, Poland was forming its own Papal empire. And, to date, 90% of Poland's 39 million citizens are Roman Catholic.
There are several stereotypes about the Poles; the obvious being that they are unintelligent or unlettered. However, one of the boons of setting up a stable government a millenia ago was the benefit of education through the Church. And, in the 12th Century, while the rest of Europe was still drinking corpse water and sleeping with fleas, Poland was working on creating a universal system of education for its citizens.
Also, one of the unnoticed (today) benefits of a highly educated peasant class was that the Black Death did not ravage the population as it did in the "civilized" areas like London, Vienna and Paris.
Nah, me and the fellas are going to skip over Warsaw and head to Flanders.
Polish girl...smarter than you, lazy Yankee.
Of course, this stereotype was largely born during WWII when Germany invaded the country, as it had on so many previous occasions. This time, Herr Hitler concocted scenes of atrocities being perpetuated against Germans living in Gdansk, on the Western border of Poland. Moreover according to Hitler, Gdansk (Danzig) always was German and wanted to remain German.
Despite what you thought you learned in your shitty American public schools, the German invasion of Poland did not initiate as a heated debate over this Danzig.
Then you know what happened. The elite Polish Cavalry, long renowned as one of the finest in world history, decided it would be a good idea to try to stymy the panzer divisions on horseback. That's right, the Blitzkrieg began as rolling tanks smashing the ponies.
Yes, you read that right...the Poles tried to stop this...
With this
And that is pretty much what Poland has faced for the past 300 years...one empire seizing it, then using it as a dumping ground, arms depot, concentration camp and/or incenerator. The Russians did it, the Germans did it, the French did, the Austrians did it. Hell, at the end of WWI, even America did it. And, being wedged between eternal enemies Germany and Russia, will take a toll on the population; even among Poland's renowned beautiful women...
Polish hottie at age 25....
Same Polish Hottie at age 30.
As to be expected from a nation that -merely 20 years ago- was a Soviet satellite with a centralized economy in tatters, Poland's transition to a market economy is still a bit wobbly. Among its exports (and Poland is a hotbed of industrialization) is one of the world's largest sources of pollution. This is not helped by an industrial infrastructure that is still a wreck. The nation's roads and bridges, long-ignored by Russia, are dubbed affectionately as "death ribbons". Poland is also fucked in that its hillsides -and little-policed backroads- apparently make great places to smuggle illegal aliens, traffick in sex workers, and import heroin from the East to a drug-starved Western Europe. Growing pains are to be expected, but Poland has been pretty resilient, and long-term success as part of the EU should only help them along....
Poland: We promise we're sorta' kinda' European.
Schatten - number of issues with this article. I'm no expert but you should consider the following: (1) The stories of cavalry charging tanks are a myth. Many notable historians have dismissed these claims as a propaganda invention by the Nazis. (2) While you rightly point out some of the Poles' early triumphs, you should also remember that the Polish Commonwealth was the largest state in Europe for quite some time, it owned the Prussians (Germans) as vassals, it as the only nation to sack Moscow (twice), beat a million-strong Russian army in 1920 shortly after winnign independence after WWI, and is considered by many historians a a "savior of Europe" for Sobieski's protection of Vienna against the Islamic armies of the Ottomans. (3) The reason Poland was wiped off the map for 127 years is actually due to the Democratic tradition it shares with the US. ~3-4 years after the Americans introduced the first Constitution to the world, Poland followed with the second such document. As a result, three monarchies afraid of a spreading revolution invaded simultaneously from the west (Germans), east (Russians), and south (Austrians). Poland was carved up and suppressed for a century as a result. (4) the French never ruled Poland and in fact Napolean established the Duchy of Warsaw, giving the Poles a short-lived state during the partition period. Not sure what the post-WWI use of Poland as a dumping ground by Americans is supposed to allude to when it was Pres Wilson that made it one of his "Points" to re-establish the Polish nation. (5) The Poles have the most thriving economy in ALL of Europe. Read any article on the subject. The claims about trafficking, etc. can be made about any nation incuding the US (in the southwest) - every nation has its underbelly (6) The Polish joke was not created as a result of WWII. In fact at one point during the civil rights movement it became crude to label African-Americans as uneducated and supid. It became popular then to shift those stereotypes and labels to white immigrants at a time when Poles made up the majority of the immigrant population.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your commentary and contributions, Anon. I understand that I did shirk the 17th-19th Century a bit, but that was more for brevity. My point in this posting was more to demonstrate that the Polish are not dumb people. Anyway, I have revisited Poland, and that is on the front page. I do stand by some of my original assertions, but have certainly clarified others. And, remember, this is all in good fun. Thanks for dropping by and come over anytime.
ReplyDeletehttp://gothlaw.blogspot.com/2009/10/your-country-is-fucked-revisiting.html
Sparta got grain from Italy but the Athenians got grain from Scythia, which became Poland. The Scythes were heavily Hellenized and intermarried with the Greeks. The Russians mingled with Varangian Vikings and Mongol Tatars and became autocratic and helped the Turks and Arabs bastardize Greece and Greek Christianity Therefore the only true heirs left for Ancient Athenian Democratic Tradition abd Erudition are the Glorious Polish people.
ReplyDeleteHave you ever thought about writing an e-book or guest authoring on other sites?
ReplyDeleteI have a blog based on the same ideas you discuss and would love to have you share some stories/information.
I know my viewers would appreciate your work. If you are even remotely interested,
feel free to send me an e mail.
my web page :: bmi chart for women